So far very pleased with boots. The are probably the most comfortable shoes I have ever weared, light, warm, dry, fits perfectly (I have a wide foot), gives good sideways support. Weared them for a week all the time, sometimes sleeping in them, and never had cold or wet feet. So far waterproof, but so far I have not had the chance to test that thoroughly. I hope they last long, too early to give five stars for value!